Sociological Forum, Volume. 17, No . 4, December 2002 ( C 2002)
Race, Racial, and Deviance: A Study of Asian and Non-Asian Adolescents in America1 Sung Joon Jang2
This study shows that Asian American adolescents devote less deviance in the form of university misbehavior than white, dark, Hispanic, or perhaps Native American adolescents. Interpersonal control and social learning theories get support while the observed differences happen to be explained mostly by race/ethnic differences in family members backgrounds and school connecting. These variables' explanatory capability tends to be invariant across 4 regional categories of Asian Americans. This research applies OLS regression to self-reported info from a nationally representative sample. KEY WORDS: Asian American; adolescent deviance; social control; social learning; race/ racial; juvenile delinquency.
INTRODUCTION Accompanied by the ongoing argument over the arbitrariness of race categorization and changes in the sociable conception and signiп¬Ѓcance of race and ethnicity (Alba, 1990; Barringer et 's., 1993; Lieberson and Marine environments, 1988; Peterson and Hagan, 1984; Pat, 1980), sociological criminologists have regarded race/ethnicity as a main demographic associate of deviance and crime. While early self-report studies argued that racial/ethnic variations in crime observed in ofп¬Ѓcial data primarily reп¬‚ect bias in the justice system against racial/ethnic minorities (e. g., Chambliss and Nagasawa, 1 An
earlier edition of this daily news was provided at the 12th International Our elected representatives on Criminology of the Foreign Society to get Criminology, Seoul, Korea, Aug, 1998. two Department of Sociology, Louisiana State School, 126 Stubbs Hall, Creux Rouge, Louisiana 70803; email-based: [email protected] edu. 647 0884-8971/02/1200-0647/0
2002 Plenum Creating Corporation
1969), victimization studies, as well as afterwards self-report studies, п¬Ѓnd that the system-bias element cannot clarify most of the noticed differences (Hindelang et al., 1979; Sampson and Lauritsen, 1997). Cross-national studies generally concur with this п¬Ѓnding (Tonry, 1997). Previous researchers, however , include given the majority of attention to whiteвЂ“ black side by side comparisons, whether they look at the race/ethnicityвЂ“crime bivariate marriage or the theoretical details, using ofп¬Ѓcial or unofп¬Ѓcial data (e. g., Elliott et approach., 1989; Hindelang et approach., 1979; Matsueda and Heimer, 1987; Sampson and Lauritsen, 1997). Asian Americans include rarely recently been a focus appealing in comparison etiological exploration. Even in gang research, they tend to receive less interest compared to additional racial organizations (Toy, 1992), and discussion of the charge of Oriental American criminality largely remains to be sketchy and frequently speculative (e. g., Bouquets, 1988). This general deficiency of interest in Asian Americans between criminologists can be partly due to their low visibility not only in demographic data3 although also in crime figures, which might include led students to truly feel less desperation to study Hard anodized cookware Americans than other racial/ethnic minorities whose criminality tends to be higher. However , their very own low criminality itself warrants systematic examination of Asian People in the usa, as much as large criminality arrest warrants the study of additional racial/ethnic minorities. Another feasible reason might be simply the unavailability of data accumulated from a representative sample which includes a relatively numerous Asian American respondents. Awkward, few criminologists have done comprehensive analysis that compares Asian Us citizens and non-Asian Americans in deviance and crime. To п¬Ѓll this kind of gap in knowledge, the present study is targeted on adolescent deviance, primarily misbehavior at university. Speciп¬Ѓcally, it п¬Ѓrst examines the empirical validity in the popular picture of Asian American adolescents as well behaved in comparison to other racial/ethnic groups, employing self-reported info from a national study, unlike previous studies that rely on ofп¬Ѓcial data, especially police-arrest data or...
References: Agnew, Robert 1990 " Adolescent assets and delinquency. вЂќ Criminology 28: 535вЂ“566. Akers, Ronald L. 1985 Deviant Patterns: A Interpersonal Learning Approach, 3rd edn. Belmont, LOS ANGELES: Wadsworth. 1997 Criminological Ideas: Introduction and Evaluation, second edn. Los Angeles: Roxbury. Samarie, Richard D. 1990 Cultural Identity: The Transformation of White America. New Destination, CT: Yale University Press. Bachman, Jerald G., Steve M. Wallace Jr., Meat M. O'Malley, Lloyd D. Johnston, Candace L. Kurth, and Harold W. Neighbors 1991 " Racial/ethnic variations in smoking ingesting, and illicit drug use among American high school elderly people, 1976вЂ“89. вЂќ American Diary of Public well-being 81: 372вЂ“377. Bankston, Carl L., 3 1998 " Youth gangs and the fresh second era: A review essay. вЂќ Out and out aggression and Chaotic Behavior 3: 35вЂ“45. Barringer, Herbert, Robert W. Gardner, and Michael jordan J. Levin 1993 Asians and Paciп¬Ѓc Islanders in america. New York: Russell Sage Base. Batta, My spouse and i. D., R. I. Mawby, and L. W. McCulloch 1981 " Crime, social problems, and Asian immigration: The Bradford experience. вЂќ International Diary of Contemporary Sociology 18: 135вЂ“ 168. Bellah, Robert N., Richard Madsen, William M. Sullivan, Ann Swidler, and Stephen M. Tipton 1985 Habits from the Heart: Individualism and Dedication in American Life. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Race, Racial, and Deviance Berg, Insoo Kim, and Ajakai Jaya 1993 " Different and same: Friends and family therapy with Asian-American households. вЂќ Diary of Significant other and Family members Therapy nineteen: 31вЂ“38. Cernkovich, Stephen, and Peggy Giordano 1992 " School developing, race, and delinquency. вЂќ Criminology 35: 261вЂ“291. Chambliss, William T., and Richard H. Nagasawa 1969 " On the quality of ofп¬Ѓcial statistics: A comparative examine of White, Black, and Japanese high-school boys. вЂќ Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency 6th: 71вЂ“77. Chin, Ko-Lin 1990 " China gangs and extortion. вЂќ In Ronald C. Huff (ed. ), Gangs in the united states: 129вЂ“145. Newbury Park, FLORIDA: Sage. Choi, Y. Elsie, Janine Bempechat, and Herbert P. Ginsburg 1994 " Educational socialization in Korean American children: A longitudinal study. вЂќ Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology 12-15: 313вЂ“ 318. Cohen, Jacob, and Patricia Cohen 1983 Applied Multiple Regression/Correlation Examination for the Behavioral Savoir, 2nd edn. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum. Elliott, Delbert H., David Huizinga, and Suzanne S. Ageton 1985 Detailing Delinquency and Drug Make use of. Newbury Recreation area, CA: Sage. Elliott, Delbert S., David Huizinga, and Scott Menard 1989 Multiple Problem Youth: Delinquency, Substance Use and Mental Medical problems. New York: Springer. Flowers, Ronald Barri 1988 Minorities and Criminality. Ny: Greenwood Press. Gottfredson, Michael jordan R., and Travis Hirschi 1990 A General Theory of Crime. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press. Hagan, Ruben, A. 3rd there’s r. Gillis, and John Simpson 1985 " The class composition of gender and delinquency: Toward a power-control theory of common delinquent behavior. вЂќ American Journal of Sociology 80: 1151вЂ“1178. Hayner, Norman S. 1933 " Delinquency areas in the Puget
677 Sound. вЂќ American Journal of Sociology 39: 314вЂ“328. 38 " Sociable factors in oriental offense. вЂќ American Journal of Sociology 43: 908вЂ“ 919. Hieshima, Joyce, and Barbara Schneider year 1994 " Intergenerational effects within the cultural and cognitive socialization of third- and fourth-generation Japanese People in america. вЂќ Diary of Utilized Developmental Mindset 15: 319вЂ“327. Hindelang, Jordan J., Travis Hirschi, and Joseph G. Weis lates 1970s " Correlates of delinquency: The impression of disparity between selfreport and ofп¬Ѓcial measures. вЂќ American Sociological Review 44: 995вЂ“1014. 81 Measuring Delinquency. Beverly Slopes, CA: Sage. Hirschi, Travis 1969 Reasons for Delinquency. Berkeley: University of California Press. 1979 " Separate and unequal is much better. вЂќ Record of Research in Criminal offenses and Delinquency 16: 34вЂ“37. Humes, Karen, and Jesse McKinnon 2150 The Hard anodized cookware and Paciп¬Ѓc Islander Inhabitants in the United States: Drive 1999 (U. S. Census Bureau, Current Population Reviews, Series P20вЂ“529). Washington, POWER: U. T. Government Creating Ofп¬Ѓce. Jang, Sung Joon 1999 " Age-varying effects of family, college, and peers on delinquency: A multilevel modeling testing of interactional theory. вЂќ Criminology 37: 643вЂ“685. Jarjoura, G. Roger 1993 " Does falling out of school enhance late involvement? Results from a considerable national likelihood sample. вЂќ Criminology 31: 149вЂ“172. Jessor, Richard, and Shirley Jessor 1977 Trouble Behavior and Psychosocial Advancement: A Longitudinal Study of Youth. Ny: Academic Press. Junger, Marianne, and Ineke Haen Marshall 1997 " The interethnic generalizability of social control theory: An empirical check. вЂќ Journal of Exploration in Crime and Delinquency 34: 79вЂ“112. Junger-Tas, Josine 1997 " Ethnic minorities and lawbreaker justice inside the Netherlands. вЂќ In Michael Tonry (ed. ), Ethnicity, Crime, and
678 Migrants: Comparative and CrossNational Perspectives, Vol. 21 years old: Crime and Justice: A Review of Research: 257вЂ“310. Chicago: School of Chicago, il Press. Kaufman, Phillip, Jin Y. Kwon, Steve Klein, and Captain christopher D. Chapman 2000 Dropout Rates in the United States: 1999 (National Center to get Education Stats, Statistical Research Report. NCES 2001-022). Wa, DC: U. S. Govt Printing Ofп¬Ѓce. Kendall, Katherine A. 1988 " The evolving relatives: An international perspective. вЂќ Worldwide Social Job 31: 81вЂ“93. Kim, Uichol, and Helen B. L. Chun year 1994 " Educational вЂsuccess' of Asian People in america: An native perspective. вЂќ Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology 15: 329вЂ“343. Kim-Raynor, Soonja, and Tazuko Shibusawa Nakasone 1981 " Sociable work practice with Hard anodized cookware American people. вЂќ Interpersonal Work Documents 16: 33вЂ“42. Kitano, Harry H. M., and Roger Daniels 1995 Asian People in america: Emerging Hispanics, 2nd edn. Englewood Coves, NJ: Prentice Hall. Krohn, Marvin G., and James L. Massey 1980 " Social control and delinquent behavior: A great examination of the elements of the social relationship. вЂќ Sociological Quarterly twenty-one: 529вЂ“543. Lee, Yoon Ho 1998 " Acculturation and delinquent tendencies: The case of Korean American youths. вЂќ International Log of Relative and Utilized Criminal Rights 22: 273вЂ“292. Lieberson, Stanley, and Jane C. Seas 1988 Coming from Many Strands: Ethnic and Racial Groupings in Modern-day America. Nyc: Russell Sage Foundation. Lin, Chien, and William Capital t. Liu 93 " Intergenerational relationships between Chinese zugezogener families via Taiwan. вЂќ In Harriette Pipes McAdoo (ed. ), Family Ethnicity: Strength in Diversity: 271вЂ“286. Newbury Park, CA: Sage. Lind, Claire W. 1930 " Several ecological habits of community disorganization in Honolulu. вЂќ
Jang American Journal of Sociology dua puluh enam: 206вЂ“ 230. Loeber, Rolf, and David P. Farrington 1998 Critical and Violent Juvenile Offenders: Risk Elements and Effective Interventions. Thousand Oaks, FLORIDA: Sage. Birmingham, Harlan, and Wynetta Devore 1988 " Layers of understanding: Therapies ethnic fraction families. вЂќ Family Contact 37: 310вЂ“314. Martens, Philip L. 97 " Immigrants, crime, and criminal justice in Sweden. вЂќ In Michael Tonry (ed. ), Ethnicity, Criminal offense, and Migrants: Comparative and Cross-National Views, Vol. twenty-one: Crime and Justice: A Review of Research: 183вЂ“ 255. Chi town: University of Chicago Press. Matsueda, Ross L., and Karen Heimer 1987 " Race, family members structure, and delinquency: A test of differential relationship and interpersonal control hypotheses. вЂќ American Sociological Review 52: 826вЂ“840. McAdoo, Harriette Pipes 93 " Cultural families: Strengths that are found in diversity. вЂќ In Harriette Pipes McAdoo (ed. ), Family Racial: Strength in Diversity: 3вЂ“14. Newbury Area, CA: Sage. Ogbu, David U. 1990 " Community education in comparative point of view. вЂќ Log of Marrano Education fifty nine: 45вЂ“57. Okada, Daniel Bill 1987 " Japanese American juvenile delinquency: An research of control theory in a Japanese American community. вЂќ PhD feuille, University of Maryland, University Park. Systems, Young-Shi, and Harriette Pipes McAdoo 1993 " Socialization of Oriental American kids. вЂќ In Harriette Plumbing McAdoo (ed. ), Relatives Ethnicity: Power in Range: 245вЂ“270. Newbury Park, LOS ANGELES: Sage. Peterson, Ruth Deb., and David Hagan 1984 " Changing conceptions of race: Toward an account of anomalous п¬Ѓndings of sentencing research. вЂќ American Sociological Review 49: 56вЂ“70. Poole, Eric Deb., and Indicate R. Pogrebin 1990 " Crime and law enforcement policy in the Korean American community. вЂќ
Race, Ethnicity, and Deviance Authorities Studies 13: 57вЂ“66. Portes, Alejandro, and Cynthia Truelove 1987 " Making sense of variety: Recent study on Mexican minorities in the us. вЂќ Total annual Review of Sociology 13: 359вЂ“385. Rutter, Michael, and Henri Giller 1983 Juvenile Delinquency: Trends and Perspectives. Harmondsworth, UK: Penguin Books. Sampson, Robert T., and Ruben H. Laub 1993 Criminal offenses in the Producing: Pathways and Turning Factors Through Lifestyle. Cambridge, MOTHER: Harvard School Press. Sampson, Robert J., and Jeremy L. Lauritsen 1997 " Racial and ethnic disparities in crime and lawbreaker justice in the United States. вЂќ In Michael Tonry (ed. ), Ethnicity, Crime, and Migration: Comparative and Cross-National Points of views, Vol. twenty-one: Crime and Justice: A Review of Research: 311вЂ“374. Chicago: College or university of Chicago Press. Sanders, Williams W. 1994 Gangbangs and Drive-Bys: Grounded Traditions and Child Gang Violence. New York: Aldine De Gruyter. Sheu, Chuen-Jim 1986 Delinquency and Identity: Juvenile Delinquency in an American Chinatown. Nyc: Harrow and Heston. Shoho, Alan R. 1994 " A famous comparison of parent involvement of three years of Japan Americans (Isseis, Niseis, Sanseis) in the education of their kids. вЂќ Log of Applied Developmental Psychology 15: 305вЂ“ 311. Jones, David F. 1997 " Ethnic origins, crime, and criminal justice in England and Wales. вЂќ In Jordan Tonry (ed. ), Racial, Crime, and Immigration: Comparative and Cross-National Perspectives, Vol. 21: Offense and Justice: A Review of Research: 101вЂ“182. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Taylor, Robert Joseph, Linda M. Chatters, M. Belinda Tucker, and Edith Lewis 1991 " Developments in research about Black family members: A decade assessment. вЂќ In Alan Booth (ed. ), Contemporary People: Looking Forward, Seeking Back: 275вЂ“
679 296. Minneapolis, MN: National Council on Family Relations. Thornberry, Terence S. 1987 " Toward an interactional theory of delinquency. вЂќ Criminology 25: 863вЂ“ 891. Thornberry, Terence G., Alan L. Lizotte, Marvin D. Krohn, Margaret Farnworth, and Being sung Joon Jang 1991 " Testing interactional theory: A great examination of testing causal associations among family members, school, and delinquency. вЂќ Journal of Criminal Regulation and Criminology 82: 3вЂ“35. Tonry, Michael 1997 " Ethnicity, criminal offenses, and migration. вЂќ In Michael Tonry (ed. ), Ethnicity, Offense, and Migrants: Comparative and Cross-National Points of views, Vol. twenty-one: Crime and Justice: A Review of Research: 1вЂ“27. Chicago: University or college of Chicago Press. Tournier, Pierre 97 " Nationality, crime, and criminal rights in England. вЂќ In Michael Tonry (ed. ), Ethnicity, Offense, and Migrants: Comparative and Cross-National Perspectives, Vol. 21: Crime and Justice: An assessment Research: 523вЂ“551. Chicago: University of Chi town Press. Toy, Calvin 1992 " A quick history of Asian gangs in San Francisco. вЂќ Justice Quarterly 9: 647вЂ“ 665. Unger, Steven 1977 The Devastation of American American indian Families. New York: Association on American Indian Affairs. Vigil, James Diego, and Sam Chong Yun 1990 " Vietnamese children gangs in southern California. вЂќ In Ronald C. Huff (ed. ), Gangs in the united states: 146вЂ“162. Newbury Park, LOS ANGELES: Sage. Marine environments, Mary C., and Karl Eschbach 1995 " Immigration and cultural and ethnic inequality in the United States. вЂќ Total annual Review of Sociology 21: 419вЂ“446. Wiatrowski, Michael D., David B. Griswold, and Mary K. Roberts 1981 " Social control theory and delinquency. вЂќ American Sociological Review 46: 525вЂ“541. Wilkinson, Doris 93 " Friends and family ethnicity in America. вЂќ In Harriette Plumbing McAdoo (ed. ), Family members
680 Ethnicity: Strength in Diversity: 15вЂ“59. Newbury Playground, CA: Sage. Wilson, William Julius 1980 The Decreasing Signiп¬Ѓcance of Race: Blacks and Changing American Organizations, 2nd edn. Chicago: University or college of Chicago Press. Pat, James Q., and Richard J. Herrnstein 1985 Offense and Being human. New York: Sue and Schuster. Wong, Siu Kwong 97 " Delinquency of Chinese-Canadian youth: A test of opportunity, control, and intergeneration conп¬‚ict theories. вЂќ Junior and Contemporary society 29: 112вЂ“133. 1999 " Acculturation, expert relations, and delinquent habit of Chinese-
Jang Canadian youth. вЂќ Adolescence 34: 107вЂ“119. Yamamoto, Joe, and Hiroshi Wagatsuma 1980 " The Japanese and Japanese People in the usa. вЂќ Journal of Detailed Psychiatry 14: 120вЂ“135. Yee, Albert L. 1992 " Asians while stereotypes and students: Misperceptions that continue. вЂќ Educational Psychology Assessment 4: 95вЂ“ 132. Yue, Ma 1993 " Family relationships, broken homes, culture pattern and delinquency in Chinese-American communities. вЂќ PhD dissertation, Rutgers, Express University of recent JerseyвЂ“Newark.